Saint Cyril of Alexandria?
Cyril of Alexandria was the Patriarch of Alexandria from 412 to 444.
Cyril is well known for his dispute with Nestorius and his supporter,
Patriarch John of Antioch, whom Cyril excluded from the Council of
Ephesus for arriving late. He is also known for his expulsion of
Novatians and Jews from Alexandria and for inflaming tensions that led
to the murder of the Hellenistic philosopher Hypatia by a Christian
mob. Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: Cyril did not receive Biblical education until he was 21 years old.
His formal education consisted of grammatical studies at ages 12 to 14
(390-392 C.E.), rhetoric and humanities at ages 15 to 20 (393-397), and
Christian theology and biblical studies in his 20s (398-402). New World
Encyclopedia.
Note: Cyril supported the ouster of John Chrysostom.
He accompanied Theophilus to Constantinople for the "Synod of the Oak"
in 402. There, Cyril supported the ouster of John Chrysostom as
archbishop of Constantinople on administrative grounds, although
Chrysostom's association with Antioch and his support of Origenism also
seem to have been a factor. Later Cyril supported John's return. New
World Encyclopedia
Note: Cyril learned how to eliminate adversaries from his uncle.
Theophilus arrived at Constantinople with twenty-nine of his suffragan
bishops, and conferring with those opposed to the Archbishop, drafted a
long list of largely unfounded accusations against Chrysostom, who
refused to recognize the legality of a synod in which his open enemies
were judges. Chrysostom was subsequently deposed. Wikipedia Encyclopedia
Note: Cyril succeeded his uncle as Patriarch after riots.
Theophilus died on 15 October 412, and Cyril was made Pope or Patriarch
of Alexandria on 18 October 412, but only after a riot between his
supporters and those of his rival Archdeacon Timotheus. According to
Socrates Scholasticus, the Alexandrians were always rioting. Catholic
Encyclopedia
Note: Cyril immediately shut down perceived heretic churches.
On the third day after the death of Theophilus, Cyril came into
possession of the episcopate, with greater power than Theophilus had
ever exercised. For from that time the bishopric of Alexandria went
beyond the limits of its sacerdotal functions and assumed the
administration of secular matters. Cyril immediately therefore shut up
the churches of the Novatians at Alexandria and took possession of all
their consecrated vessels and ornaments; and then stripped their bishop
Theopemptus of all that he had. Socrates and Sozomenus Ecclesiastical
Histories, Volume 2, Chapter 7
Note: Cyril led the expulsion of Jews from Alexandria.
Cyril also ordered all Jews be expelled from the city, which housed one
of the largest Jewish communities of the Roman Empire. This was opposed
by the prefect of Alexandria, Orestes, but Cyril paid no heed and the
Jews were expelled. Socrates describes the events as follows: Cyril,
accompanied by an immense crowd of people, going to their
synagogues—-for so they call their house of prayer-—took them away from
(the synagogues) and drove the Jews out of the city, permitting the
multitude to plunder their goods. Thus, the Jews who had inhabited the
city from the time of Alexander the Macedonian were expelled from it,
stripped of all they possessed, and dispersed some in one direction and
some in another. Socrates and Sozomenus Ecclesiastical Histories,
Volume 2, Chapter 13
Note: Cyril instigated a riot against Orestes the perfect of Alexandria.
Nonetheless, with Cyril's banishment of the Jews, "Orestes [...] was
filled with great indignation at these transactions and was excessively
grieved that a city of such magnitude should have been suddenly bereft
of so large a portion of its population." After Cyril and Orestes both
appealed to the emperor regarding the matter, some 500 zealous monks
from Nitria descended on the city in support of Cyril's cause. They
confronted Orestes and stoned him nearly to death, accusing him of
paganism and idolatry over his protestations that he was a baptized and
believing Christian. The populace of Alexandria rescued Orestes from
certain death at the hands of the monks. One monk, Ammonius, was
captured and put to death. Cyril tried to make Ammonius a martyr, but
sober-minded Christians did not recognize him as such. Socrates and
Sozomenus Ecclesiastical Histories, Volume 2, Chapter 14
Note: Cyril instigated the murder of a leading Alexandria philosopher.
There was a woman at Alexandria named Hypatia, daughter of the
philosopher Theon, who made such attainments in literature and science,
as to far surpass all the philosophers of her own time. Having
succeeded in the school of Plato and Plotinus, she explained the
principles of philosophy to her auditors, many of whom came from a
distance to receive her instructions. Because of self-possession and
ease of manner, which she had acquired as a consequence of the
cultivation of her mind, she not unfrequently appeared in public in
presence of the magistrates. Neither did she feel abashed in coming to
an assembly of men. For all men on account of her extraordinary dignity
and virtue admired her the more. Yet she even fell victim to the
political jealousy which at that time prevailed. For as she had
frequent interviews with Orestes, it was calumniously reported among
the Christian populace, that it was she who prevented Orestes from
being reconciled to the bishop. Some of them therefore, hurried away by
a fierce and bigoted zeal, whose ringleader was a reader named Peter,
waylaid her returning home, and dragging her from her carriage, they
took her to the church called Cęsareum, where they completely stripped
her, and then murdered her with tiles. After tearing her body in
pieces, they took her mangled limbs to a place called Cinaron, and
there burnt them. This affair brought harsh criticism, not only upon
Cyril, but also upon the whole Alexandrian church. And surely nothing
can be farther from the spirit of Christianity than the allowance of
massacres, fights, and transactions of that sort. This happened in the
month of March during Lent, in the fourth year of Cyril’s episcopate,
under the tenth consulate of Honorius, and the sixth of Theodosius.
Socrates and Sozomenus Ecclesiastical Histories, Volume 2, Chapter 15
Note: Cyril wanted to dominate the eastern churches.
Another major conflict was between the Alexandrian and Antiochian
schools of ecclesiastical reflection, piety, and discourse. This long
running conflict widened with the third canon of the First Council of
Constantinople which granted the see of Constantinople primacy over the
older sees of Alexandria and Antioch. Thus, the struggle between the
sees of Alexandria and Antioch now included Constantinople. The
conflict came to a head in 428 after Nestorius, who originated in
Antioch, was made Archbishop of Constantinople. The First Seven
Ecumenical Councils (325-787 The Liturgical Press, 1983, pp. 136–148
Note: Cyril defended the Mary is “Mother of God” concept.
Cyril gained an opportunity to restore Alexandria's pre-eminence over
both Antioch and Constantinople when an Antiochine priest who was in
Constantinople at Nestorius' behest began to preach against calling
Mary the "Mother of God" (Theotokos). As the term "Mother of God" had
long been attached to Mary, the laity in Constantinople complained
against the priest. Rather than repudiating the priest, Nestorius
intervened on his behalf. Nestorius argued that Mary was neither a
"Mother of Man" nor "Mother of God" as these referred to Christ's two
natures; rather, Mary was the "Mother of Christ" (Greek: Christotokos).
Christ, according to Nestorius, was the conjunction of the Godhead with
his "temple" (which Nestorius was fond of calling his human nature).
The controversy seemed to be centered on the issue of the suffering of
Christ. The theology of St. Cyril of Alexandria: a critical
appreciation, p. 49.
Note: Nestorius used Scripture in his letters to Cyril.
Again, I should like to expand on this but am restrained by the memory
of my promise. I must speak therefore but with brevity. Holy scripture,
wherever it recalls the Lord's economy, speaks of the birth and
suffering not of the godhead but of the humanity of Christ, so that the
holy virgin is more accurately termed mother of Christ than mother of
God. Hear these words that the gospels proclaim: "The book of the
generation of Jesus Christ, son of David, son of Abraham." It is clear
that God the Word was not the son of David. Listen to another witness
if you will: "Jacob begat Joseph, the husband of Mary, of whom was born
Jesus, who is called the Christ. " Consider a further piece of
evidence: "Now the birth of Jesus Christ took place in this way. When
his mother Mary had been betrothed to Joseph, she was found to be with
child of the holy Spirit." But who would ever consider that the godhead
of the only begotten was a creature of the Spirit? Why do we need to
mention: "the mother of Jesus was there"? And again, what of: "with
Mary the mother of Jesus"; or "that which is conceived in her is of the
holy Spirit"; and "Take the child and his mother and flee to Egypt";
and "concerning his Son, who was born of the seed of David according to
the flesh"? Again, scripture says when speaking of his passion: "God
sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh and for sin, he
condemned sin in the flesh"; and again "Christ died for our sins" and
"Christ having suffered in the flesh"; and "This is", not "my godhead",
but "my body, broken for you". Ten thousand other expressions witness
to the human race that they should not think that it was the godhead of
the Son that was recently killed but the flesh which was joined to the
nature of the godhead. (Hence also Christ calls himself the lord and
son of David: " 'What do you think of the Christ? Whose son is he?'
They said to him, 'The son of David.' Jesus answered and said to them,
'How is it then that David inspired by the Spirit, calls him Lord,
saying, "The Lord said to my Lord, sit at my right hand"?'". He said
this as being indeed son of David according to the flesh, but his Lord
according to his godhead.) The body therefore is the temple of the
deity of the Son, a temple which is united to it in a high and divine
conjunction, so that the divine nature accepts what belongs to the body
as its own. Such a confession is noble and worthy of the gospel
traditions. But to use the expression "accept as its own" as a way of
diminishing the properties of the conjoined flesh, birth, suffering and
entombment, is a mark of those whose minds are led astray, my brother,
by Greek thinking or are sick with the lunacy of Apollinarius and Arius
or the other heresies or rather something more serious than these.
Nestorius second epistle to Cyril of Alexandria.
Note: Cyril ensured Nestorius would lose at the Council of Ephesus.
At Easter 429 A.D., Cyril wrote a letter to the Egyptian monks warning
them of Nestorius's views. A copy of this letter reached Constantinople
where Nestorius preached a sermon against it. This began a series of
letters between Cyril and Nestorius which gradually became more
strident in tone. Finally, Emperor Theodosius II convoked the Council
of Ephesus (in 431) to solve the dispute. Cyril selected Ephesus as the
venue since it supported the veneration of Mary. The council was
convoked before Nestorius's supporters from Antioch and Syria had
arrived and thus Nestorius refused to attend when summoned.
Predictably, the Council ordered the deposition and exile of Nestorius
for heresy. Socrates and Sozomenus Ecclesiastical Histories, Volume 2,
Chapter 34
Note: Cyril was condemned of heresy after all the bishops arrived.
However, when John of Antioch and the other pro-Nestorius bishops
finally reached Ephesus, they assembled their own Council, condemned
Cyril for heresy, deposed him from his see, and labelled him as a
"monster, born and educated for the destruction of the church".
Theodosius, by now old enough to hold power by himself, annulled the
verdict of the Council and arrested Cyril, but Cyril eventually
escaped. Having fled to Egypt, Cyril bribed Theodosius's courtiers, and
sent a mob led by Dalmatius, a hermit, to besiege Theodosius's palace,
and shout abuse; the emperor eventually gave in, sending Nestorius into
minor exile (Upper Egypt). Cyril died about 444, but the controversies
were to continue for decades, from the "Robber Synod" of Ephesus (449)
to the Council of Chalcedon (451) and beyond. Decline and Fall of the
Roman Empire, page 47.
Note: Cyril did not believe in forgiveness or unity.
Not long after these events, John bishop of Antioch made his
appearance; and being informed of what had taken place, he pronounced
unqualified censure on Cyril as the author of all this confusion, in
having so precipitately proceeded to the deposition of Nestorius. Upon
this Cyril combined with Juvenal to revenge themselves on John, and
they deposed him also. When affairs reached this confused condition,
Nestorius saw that the contention which had been raised was thus
tending to the destruction of communion, in bitter regret he called
Mary Theotocos, and cried out: ‘Let Mary be called Theotocos, if you
will, and let all disputing cease.’ But although he made this
recantation, no notice was taken of it; for his deposition was not
revoked, and he was banished to the Oasis, where he still remains. Such
was the conclusion of this Synod. These things were done on the 28th of
June, under the consulate of Bassus and Antiochus. Socrates and
Sozomenus Ecclesiastical Histories, Volume 2, Chapter 34
After his deposition Nestorius was banished to the Oasis, as above
stated. This Oasis was ‘a miserable place exposed to the wild nomad
tribes; all around were shifting sands, forming a pathless solitude.
He…employed himself in writing a defense of the opinions for which he
had lost all. The Blemmyes at length invaded the Oasis, and took
Nestorius, among others, captive; then, by what he calls a most
unexpected act of compassion, released him, and bade him hurry away. He
thought it best to proceed to Panopolis in the Thebaid, and voluntarily
reported himself to the governor, who, unmoved by his pathetic entreaty
that the imperial authorities would not be less merciful than the
barbarians, ordered some soldiers to convey him to Elephantine. The
journey under such circumstances exhausted the old man; a fall severely
hurt his hand and side; and before he could reach Elephantine, a
mandate came for his return to Panopolis. Two more compulsory changes
of abode were added to sufferings which remind us perforce of the last
days of S. John Chrysostom; and then the unhappy Nestorius was no more.
The exact year of his death cannot be ascertained.’—W. BRIGHT, Hist. of
the Church from A.D. 313 to 451, p. 371, 372.
Note: Cyril was the catalyst for the glorification of Mary heresy.
Cyril of Alexandria became noted in Church history because of his
spirited fight for the title "Theotokos" during the First Council of
Ephesus (431). His writings include the homily given in Ephesus and
several other sermons. Some of his alleged homilies are in dispute as
to his authorship. In several writings, Cyril focuses on the love of
Jesus to his mother. On the Cross, he overcomes his pain and thinks of
his mother. At the wedding in Cana, he bows to her wishes. Cyril
created the basis for all other mariological developments through his
teaching of the blessed Virgin Mary, as the "Mother of God." The
conflict with Nestorius was mainly over this issue, and it has often
been misunderstood. "The debate was not so much about Mary as about
Jesus. The question was not what honors were due to Mary, but how one
was to speak of the birth of Jesus." St. Cyril received an important
recognition of his preachings by the Second Council of Constantinople
(553 d.C.) which declared: "St. Cyril who announced the right faith of
Christians" (Anathematism XIV, Denzinger et Schoenmetzer 437). The
Story of Christianity, Volume 1: The Early Church to the Dawn of the
Reformation. New York: HarperOne. p. 254
Note: Cyril would have decreed Luke as an apostate.
Then they returned to Jerusalem from the mount called Olivet, which is
near Jerusalem, a Sabbath day's journey. And when they had entered,
they went up into the upper room where they were staying: Peter, James,
John, and Andrew; Philip and Thomas; Bartholomew and Matthew; James the
son of Alphaeus and Simon the Zealot; and Judas the son of James. These
all continued with one accord in prayer and supplication, with the
women and Mary the mother of Jesus, and with His brothers. Acts 1:12-14
MAIN INDEX
BIBLE INDEX
HINDU INDEX
MUSLIM INDEX
MORMON INDEX
BUDDHISM INDEX
WORD FAITH INDEX
WATCHTOWER INDEX
MISCELLANEOUS INDEX