Critique of THE PROTESTANT'S DILEMMA by Devin Rose
Chapter 14 - Misinterpreting the Great Commission
Page 101:
Thousands of Protestants work as full-time missionaries in far-off
lands. Yet during the time of the Reformation and for centuries after,
almost no Protestants went on any missions at all! This is because the
founders of Protestantism believed the Great Commission – Jesus’
command to evangelize all peoples – applied only to the apostles.
Note: Thousands of Catholics went on missions to collect money by selling indulgencies.
However, the later Middle Ages saw the growth of considerable abuses.
Greedy commissaries sought to extract the maximum amount of money for
each indulgence. Professional "pardoners" (quaestores in Latin) - who
were sent to collect alms for a specific project - practiced the
unrestricted sale of indulgences. Many of these quaestores exceeded
official Church doctrine, whether in avarice or ignorant zeal, and
promised rewards like salvation from eternal damnation in return for
money. Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Page 101: The Great Commission
is described in the last verses of Matthew’s Gospel. When Jesus is
about to ascend to heaven, he gives the apostles the command to go out
into all the nations to baptize and teach them. Protestants today
confidently point to those verses as the biblical motivation for their
missionary activities, but most of them don’t realize that this
interpretation is a fairly recent novelty within their ranks.
Note: Most Catholics don’t realize that indulgences were reinterpreted in 1967.
By the bull Indulgentiarum doctrina of 1 January 1967, Pope Paul VI,
responding to suggestions made at the Second Vatican Council,
substantially revised the practical application of the traditional
doctrine. Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Pages 101-102: Indeed, for a
few hundred years after the Reformation, Protestants understood this
passage as Jesus’ telling the apostles only to go and spread the Good
News, and they believed that this work had been accomplished
sufficiently in the apostolic age. The Bible was their sole rule of
faith, and the Bible said nothing about the Commission extending beyond
the apostles.
Note: The Catholic Church began early to levy requirements for forgiveness.
The Council of Epaone in 517 witnesses to the rise of the practice of
replacing severe canonical penances with a new milder penance: its 29th
canon reduced to two years the penance that apostates were to undergo
on their return to the Church, but obliged them to fast one day in
three during those two years, to come to church and take their place at
the penitents' door, and to leave with the catechumens. Any who
objected to the new arrangement were to observe the much longer ancient
penance. Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Page 102: Early Protestants
believed that Christ’s Second Coming was near at hand, so why set out
on evangelizing missions? Further, they believed that God would take
care of converting non-Christians in his own good time, basing this
belief on the fact that God doesn’t need any help making converts.
Note: The Apostles believed the Second Coming was near at hand.
And let us consider one another in order to stir up love and good
works, not forsaking the assembling of ourselves together, as is the
manner of some, but exhorting one another, and so much the more as you
see the Day approaching. Hebrews 10:24-25.
Page 102: Calvin and Luther
believed that the primary “missionary” need was to reform Catholics.
Calvin also argued that it was the duty of the Christian state or
province – not the individual believer or even the churches themselves
– to evangelize non-Christians. These beliefs strike most Protestants
today as woefully erroneous, but they are consistent with
Protestantism’s founding principles.
Note: Catholics used torture and murder on those who did not repent and convert.
When a suspect was convicted of unrepentant heresy, the inquisitorial
tribunal was required by law to hand the person over to the secular
authorities for final sentencing, at which point the penalty would be
determined by a magistrate, usually burning at the stake although the
penalty varied based on local law. The laws were inclusive of
proscriptions against certain religious crimes (heresy, etc.), and the
punishments included death by burning, although imprisonment for life
or banishment would usually be used. Thus the inquisitors generally
knew what would be the fate of anyone so remanded, and cannot be
considered to have divorced the means of determining guilt from its
effects. Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Page 103: By interpreting
Scripture themselves, apart from the Church’s magisterium and Sacred
Tradition, the Reformers established a novel tradition of their own
that acted as a powerful influence over all Protestantism for hundreds
of years. This no-need-for-missionaries tradition colored the lens
through which other Protestants read the Bible, and only after several
centuries was this tradition scrutinized and eventually discarded.
Note: The magisterium eventually discarded the use of the hostile inquisition after hundreds of years.
The institution of the Inquisition persisted until the early 19th
century (except within the Papal States) after the Napoleonic wars in
Europe and after the Spanish American wars of independence in the
Americas. The institution survived as part of the Roman Curia but was
given the new name "Supreme Sacred Congregation of the Holy Office" in
1904. In 1965 it became the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Page 103: While the Reformers
were staying home with their novel interpretation of these verses,
content to poach Catholics away from Rome, one of the greatest
missionaries of all time, St. Francis Xavier, was leaving Europe’s
shores for Asia to bring the gospel to peoples who had never heard it:
in Japan, Borneo, and India.
Note: St. Francis Xavier participated in the Portuguese inquisition.
The role of Francis Xavier in the Goa Inquisition is controversial. He
had written to King João III of Portugal in 1546, encouraging him to
dispatch the Inquisition to Goa, which he did many years later in 1560.
Francis Xavier passed away in 1552 without living to see the horrors of
the Goa Inquisition, but some historians believe that he was aware of
the Portuguese Inquisition's brutality. In an interview to an Indian
newspaper, historian Teotónio de Souza stated that Francis Xavier and
Simão Rodrigues, another founder-member of the Society of Jesus, were
together in Lisbon before Francis left for India. Both were asked to
assist spiritually the prisoners of the Inquisition and were present at
the very first Auto-da-fé celebrated in Portugal in September 1540, at
which 23 were absolved and two were condemned to be burnt, including a
French cleric. Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Pages 103-104: This mission for
Catholics to evangelize does not belong only to the great saints. It is
a call for all of us and has been since the beginning. In the twentieth
century, Pope Paul VI reaffirmed that “the task of evangelizing all
people constitutes the essential mission of the Church.” He also
explained, “On all Christians therefore is laid the preeminent
responsibility of working to make the divine message of salvation known
and accepted by all men throughout the world.” The history of the
Catholic Church, even prior to the Reformation, demonstrates consistent
commitment to spreading the gospel of Christ to the ends of the earth.
Note: Much of the history of the Catholic Church is anti-Christian.
In the Late Middle Ages and early Renaissance, the concept and scope of
the Inquisition was significantly expanded in response to the
Protestant Reformation and the Catholic Counter-Reformation. Its
geographic scope was expanded to other European countries, resulting in
the Spanish Inquisition and Portuguese Inquisition. Those two kingdoms
in particular operated inquisitorial courts throughout their respective
empires (Spanish and Portuguese) in the Americas, Asia, and Africa.
Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Page 104: Of course, with the benefit of hindsight we know that the end of days was not imminent in the 1500’s.
Note: With the benefit of hindsight we know the Second Coming was not 1,900 years ago.
But this I say, brethren, the time is short, so that from now on even
those who have wives should be as though they had none, those who weep
as though they did not weep, those who rejoice as though they did not
rejoice, those who buy as though they did not possess, and those who
use this world as not misusing it. For the form of this world is
passing away. 1 Corinthians 7:29-31.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
Page 104: If Protestantism is
true, either the founders of Protestantism made a huge blunder in
interpreting the scriptural Great Commission, establishing a
centuries-long precedent that Protestants do not go on missions, or
they were right, and Protestant missionaries today are wasting their
time on a pointless and unbiblical exercise.
Note: If Catholicism is true, then the magisterium made a huge anti-Christian blunder.
The scandalous conduct of the "pardoners" was an immediate occasion of
the Protestant Reformation. In 1517, Pope Leo X offered indulgences for
those who gave alms to rebuild St. Peter's Basilica in Rome. The
aggressive marketing practices of Johann Tetzel in promoting this cause
provoked Martin Luther to write his Ninety-Five Theses, condemning what
he saw as the purchase and sale of salvation. In Thesis 28 Luther
objected to a saying attributed to Tetzel: "As soon as a coin in the
coffer rings, a soul from purgatory springs". The Ninety-Five Theses
not only denounced such transactions as worldly but denied the Pope's
right to grant pardons on God's behalf in the first place: the only
thing indulgences guaranteed, Luther said, was an increase in profit
and greed, because the pardon of the Church was in God's power alone.
Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Note: The author must be a poor student of history or a hypocrite.
MAIN INDEX
BIBLE INDEX
HINDU INDEX
MUSLIM
INDEX
MORMON INDEX
BUDDHISM INDEX
BAPTISMAL INDEX
WORD FAITH INDEX
WATCHTOWER INDEX
MISCELLANEOUS INDEX
CATHOLIC CHURCH INDEX