Book of Mormon & Solomon Spaulding - 1952
Pittsburgh Press – July 24, 1952
Book of Mormon
By William A, White
Press Staff Writer
Amity, Pa. --
Was the famous "Book of Mormon" written under another title by Rev. Solomon
Spaulding, who died here in 1816? Innumerable arguments have failed to settle
this question.
The story is that a printer in Pittsburgh copied a story written by Rev.
Spaulding entitled "The Manuscript Found." And with the guidance of Joseph
Smith, founder of the Mormon religion, it reportedly was revised, called "The
Book of Mormon" and published as the translation of inscribed gold plates dug
from the earth near [sic] New York City.
Dr. Spaulding, graduate of Dartmouth, came here several years before his death.
He was an antiquarian who traveled far to investigate Indian mounds and trace
aborigines.
Style Resembled Old Testament
While living near Ashtabula, Ohio, he
investigated mounds and found traces of forts there supposedly built by an
extinct race and conceived the idea of a fictional sketch of this race.
According to his widow, his object in writing it was to amuse himself and
entertain his neighbors.
Written in a style resembling that of the Old Testament, he read the story to
neighbors as it progressed. The report got abroad that he was writing from his
deciphering of hieroglyphics on stone in the strange places he visited. Actually
it was a fabulous historical romance stemming from his own imagination which he
never intended to publish. An editor was permitted to read it and offered the
minister a contract for publication.
Mrs. Spaulding, in a letter published in 1839, said her husband refused to
permit its publication, but historians do not agree on this point. It was while
the editor had the manuscript Sidney Rigdon, a printer, reportedly got
possession of it long enough to copy it.
Book Published in 1830
About 1830 Joseph Smith founded the Mormon
Church, claiming that he had received his "revelation" seven years before and
had been "led" by an "angel" to the burial place of some inscribed golden
plates. In 1827 he said the "records" were delivered to him and translated into
"The Book of Mormon." The book was published in 1830 at Palmyra, N. Y. and not
too long afterward Smith was joined by printer Rigdon in Kirtland, Ohio, where
the first Mormon Temple was built.
Persons who heard Rev. Spaulding read chapters of his fiction tale claimed
immediately [that] the "Book of Mormon" appeared to be what they had heard from
Rev. Spaulding's lips, with some revisions.
According to the Minister's widow the original manuscript was sent to the Ohio
town and compared paragraph by paragraph with the text of the "Book of Mormon"
and it was identical except for "a few pious expressions and extracts from
Sacred Scriptures," which had been inserted. The author was denounced as having
"palmed it off on deluded fanatics as divine" and "should be exposed to the
contempt and execration he so justly deserved."
Strangely, the Spaulding manuscript disappeared after that and some historians
are of the opinion there never was such a manuscript, though they have no
explanation for how the story of it became so widespread and so controversial.
Rev. Spaulding's burial place in the Lower Ten Mile Presbyterian Cemetery here
is marked by a modern granite stone.
Note: The writer of the above article appears to have merely paraphrased the
1839 statement of Spalding's widow, carrying over from it certain allegations
which require careful explanation, if they are to be advanced as part of the
Spalding authorship claims (i. e. Rigdon being a printer, Spalding being "an
antiquarian who traveled far," etc.). The writer appears to be unaware of the
Spalding manuscript discovered in Hawaii and the subsequent attempts by LDS and
RLDS leaders to describe that document as Mr. Spalding's only attempt at writing
historical fiction. The above article is somewhat unusual in its promotion of
the Solomon Spalding claims for Book of Mormon authorship as late as 1952. By
that time most writers for the public press had followed the lead of Fawn M.
Brodie and had dropped the "Spalding theory" from their telling of Mormon
origins.